The reduction in the NEET PG 2024 cut-off has sparked significant debate within the medical community
Why NEET PG 2024
Cut-off Reduction Raises Concerns?
The reduction in
the NEET PG 2024 cut-off has sparked
significant debate within the medical community. While the move aims to address
vacant postgraduate medical seats, it also raises questions about its impact on
the quality of medical education and healthcare in India.
Key Details of NEET PG 2024 Cut-off Reduction
Revised Cut-off Percentile:
·
General/EWS:
15%
·
SC/ST/OBC/PwD:
10%
Purpose: To fill
vacant postgraduate medical seats.
Despite these changes, many medical
professionals are concerned about the implications of such a drastic reduction. Below
are key points of discussion:
|
Pros |
Cons |
|
Fills vacant
medical seats |
Compromises
quality of education and training |
|
Addresses issues
of resource use |
Risks
commercialization of medical education |
|
Provides
opportunities for more candidates |
Dilutes standards
of healthcare and clinical exposure |
Expert Opinions
Concerns About Quality
Dr. Shubham Anand: Criticized the move, citing the lack of
infrastructure and qualified faculty in many newly opened colleges. “The
unplanned increase in colleges and seats has led to inadequately trained
medical graduates,” he said.
Dr. Rohan Krishnan: Compared poorly equipped medical colleges to
“tea shops without ingredients.” He warned that graduates from such
institutions could weaken India’s healthcare system over the next decade.
Misuse by Private
Colleges
Dr. Dhruv Chauhan: Warned that reducing the cut-off could lead
to the commercialization of medical education. He urged stricter oversight to
ensure seats are not sold at high prices.
The Rapid Expansion of Medical Education
Medical College
Growth (2014-2024):
·
Number of Colleges: Increased by 102%
·
MBBS Seats: Increased by 130%
·
PG Seats: Increased by 135%
|
Year |
Medical Seats Vacant |
|
2022 |
96,077 |
|
2021 |
92,065 |
|
2020 |
83,275 |
While these
expansions have increased opportunities, the focus on quantity over quality
remains a major concern. Many private colleges charge exorbitant fees without
providing adequate facilities, making them less appealing to students.
What NEET PG Candidates Look For
Candidates
prioritize the following when selecting a medical college:
·
Location: Proximity to home and accessibility.
·
Quality of Education: Availability of experienced faculty and
clinical exposure.
·
Infrastructure: Adequate facilities and patient flow.
Student Perspectives
A candidate from
Haryana chose not to join due to the remote location and limited resources of
the allotted college.
A doctor from Assam
cited language barriers and lack of specialization options as reasons for
skipping the counseling process.
Previous Trends in NEET PG Cut-off Reductions
In 2023, the
qualifying percentile was reduced to zero for all categories, while in 2022,
the general category cut-off dropped from 50th to 35th percentile. However,
these reductions still left many seats vacant, as shown below:
|
Year |
General Cut-off
(%) |
SC/ST/OBC Cut-off
(%) |
Seats Vacant |
|
2023 |
0 |
0 |
High |
|
2022 |
35 |
20 |
High |
Summary
The NEET PG 2024 cut-off reduction attempts
to tackle the issue of vacant seats but has triggered concerns about the
long-term impact on medical education and healthcare standards in India. With
an increasing number of medical seats but inadequate infrastructure and
faculty, experts are calling for better regulatory oversight and
quality-focused reforms.
For more updates and expert opinions on medical education and NEET-related news, visit Edumyra.
For such useful informative details and getting help regarding any B School related query or searching the best MBA Colleges in Pune, MBA Colleges in Delhi-NCR, MBA Colleges in Mumbai, etc.
Please check Edumyra. Also, we are here to give all the info on exams like CAT/XAT/SNAP, etc.
Note:-All information on this website is subjected to updates. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided.